Kirkland Signature Irish Whiskey vs Jameson: A Tasting Comparison

When it comes to whiskey enthusiasts, few brands are as iconic as Jameson. The triple-distilled Irish whiskey has been a staple in many bars and homes for centuries. But what about its budget-friendly counterpart, Kirkland Signature Irish Whiskey? In this article, we'll dive into the differences between these two whiskeys and explore which one comes out on top.

The Finish: A Harsh Jet Fuel Aftertaste

One of the biggest drawbacks of Kirkland's whiskey is its finish. Characterized by a harsh jet fuel aftertaste and a burning sensation, it can be overwhelming for some palates. In contrast, Jameson's finish is smoother and more refined, with subtle notes of honey and green apple.

Initial Taste: Sweetness and Subtlety

When we first poured the whiskey into our glasses, Kirkland's signature Irish whiskey surprised us with a clean and subtle sweetness that quickly dissipated. This was followed by hints of light oak and citrus undertones, which provided a delicate but feels like watered-down Jameson.

Palate: A Harmonious Balance

As we explored the palate of Costco's Irish whiskey, we noticed a harmonious balance of candied orange zest, baked banana, and creamy caramel. The dry and cooked fruit notes, primarily apple, danced on our taste buds.

Comparison: Sweetness and Flavor Profile

While Kirkland's whiskey has notable sweetness and tastes like a weak Jameson, the latter boasts a richer flavor profile with subtle floral and dried fruit notes, complemented by hints of caramel and a more pronounced alcohol note or burn.

Conclusion: A Budget-Friendly Option

In conclusion, while Kirkland Signature Irish Whiskey may not boast as extensive a list of awards as Jameson, it's a budget-friendly option that offers its own unique charm. For those looking for a lighter whiskey with dried fruit notes, caramel, apple, and lingering sweetness, Costco's offering might be the perfect choice.

Kirkland vs Jameson Irish Whiskey Cheat Sheet

* Price: Kirkland Signature Irish whiskey (1.75 liters) is cheaper than triple-distilled Jameson whiskey

* Awards: Jameson has garnered numerous accolades, cementing its status as a globally recognized Irish whiskey

* Flavor Profile: Kirkland's whiskey is light with dried fruit notes, caramel, apple, and lingering sweetness; Jameson is known for its signature triple-distilled, lightly floral, and fruity notes with hints of spice

In the end, it comes down to personal preference. If you're looking for a budget-friendly option that still packs a punch, Kirkland Signature Irish Whiskey might be the way to go. But if you're willing to splurge on a premium whiskey with a rich history and heritage, Jameson is the clear winner.

The Verdict: A close competition between two whiskeys that cater to different tastes and budgets. Whether you choose Kirkland or Jameson, there's no denying the joy of sipping on a fine Irish whiskey.

Jameson whiskey 1.75